| |
NOTES
|
ANTICS SE = ANTICS SPECIAL LIMITED
EDITION
GLOS.W.R.
SE = GLOUCESTERSHIRE & WARWICKSHIRE RAILWAY
SPECIAL EDITION
PL =
PLATE REFERENCE IN KEITH MONTAGUES BOOK
" PRIVATE OWNER WAGONS FROM THE GLOUCESTER
RAILWAY CARRIAGE AND WAGON COMPANY LTD"
OXFORD PUBLISHING COMPANY 1981 SBN 86093 124 2
POPE
= PAGE REFERENCE FROM IAN POPE'S BOOK "
PRIVATE OWNER WAGONS IN THE FOREST OF DEAN" LIGHTMOOR PRESS 2002 ISBN 1 899889
09 4
G =
MODEL WAGON FITTED WITH GRCW "G" PLATES
|
| OWNER |
FLEET
NO |
TARE |
LOAD |
DATE |
DATA
SOURCE |
FIDELITY
TO SOURCE MATERIAL |
HORNBY
|
8 PLANK OPEN WAGONS SIDE
DOORS AND ONE END DOOR
|
 |
| ADLER & ALLAN |
107
|
7-2-0
|
12T
|
1936
|
PL3
|
AS PER PLATE
|
| Hornby
Reference R6212. Although the 16' x 7' 7
1/4" x 4' 7 3/8" prototype left Bristol
Road in September 1936 with white wall tyres,
this is on the face of it one of the best models
of a Gloucester Railway Carriage and Wagon
product ever made. The body shape and markings
are spot on, the G-Plate is correctly positioned
on wooden solebar, the planks of the wooden floor
even have a grain and the inner door planking has
also been attempted. But looking at the A in
ADLER and the 0 in 107, two holes appear that are
definitely not on official photograph 6025. The
upper hole is to take the hinge of the tipping
end door and the lower one is for a horrible
toy-like actuation device. This can be seen
installed on the H. C. Bull wagon below ( and
cunningly placed face down when the wagon is
boxed at the Hornby factory I might add! ) and
both bodies have an unprototypical
"doorstop" section moulded inside to
take the shaft of this piece of metal. On the
basis that it is easier to take parts off an
injection mould than add them, can Hornby please
think about a future run of these wagons without
unsightly holes and intrusions for serious
modellers? They really are the only things that
spoil an otherwise superlative effort, even down
to the drawgear springing and vacuum cylinder
moulded on the underside. |
 |
| H.C.
BULL & CO LTD |
101 |
7-0-0 |
13T |
1942 |
PL74 |
MARKINGS
ALMOST AS PER PLATE |
 |
| Hornby
Reference R6303. All the construction comments
about R6212 above also apply to this model, the
prototype of which left Bristol Road, Gloucester
- with white wall tyres - as late as September
1942. By May 1943 coal merchants such as E.K.
Shipp of Leicester and later A.J. Salter of
London ( see Airfix and
Bachmann
page ) were taking delivery of wagons from
Gloucester in plain austerity markings so this
patriotically red, white and blue livery marked
nearly the end of flamboyant private owner coal
wagon paintwork. However, holes and metalwork
aside, my gripe with this Hornby offering is that
the white diagonal stripe is supposed to indicate
the tipping door end to shunters working in the
blackout in much the same way that white platform
edges were introduced during 1939-45 for the
protection of passengers. The other side of the
wagon is correct, but sadly not this one! The
prototype measurements were 16' 1 1/4" x 7'
71/4" x 4' 7" and the data on the side
of the wagon with the unusual 13 ton load
allocation reads "Depots at Tufnell Park,
LNER, Upper Holloway LMS, South Tottenham
LMS." Note too that although both London
based eight plank wagons had just one G-Plate per
solebar - indicating ownership rather than
leasing - the H.C. Bull fleet did not seem to
have participated in the RCH Commuted Charge and
Commuted Empty Haulage Schemes. Perhaps these
wagons worked on more regular duties closer to
home than those of Adler and Allan. In fact H.C. Bull 101 was ordered
from Gloucester RCW in April 1942 and two other
Railway Clearing House standard 13 ton 8 plankers
ordered at the same time for G & S Bull of
the same address - 109 Cornwallis Road, London.
In all cases, oak frames were specified.However,
as the three wagons - most likely numbered 100 -
102 - would have been subject to wartime wagon
pooling arangements and then Nationalisation it
may be that Bull's got very little use from them!
Nevertheless, the company - a small coal merchant
by London standards -survived the Second World
War and were based at 613 Holloway Road and also
Hampden Road in 1951. The Tottenham depot - now
on the London Midland Region of British Railways
- was by this time operated by Bull of Tottenham.
Four more wagons were
delivered from Gloucester RCW in February 1946
and added to a fleet including wagons 98 and 99
built by Thomas Hunter of Rugby in 1924. Coal for
Bull would have come from Warwickshire,
Leicestershire, Nottinghamshire or Derbyshire
depending on the depot being supplied.
|
7 PLANK OPEN WAGONS SIDE
DOORS, ONE END DOOR AND BOTTOM DOORS
|
 |
| I.W. BALDWIN |
15
|
5-17-1
|
10T
|
1906
|
PL19
|
MARKINGS AS PER PLATE
|
| Hornby
Reference R6238. In favour of the outside of this
model wagon are the correct markings and body
style ( albeit with incorrect diagonal side
bracing ). Against, this model does not have the
white wall tyres as newly outshopped and
underneath is the simple inscription "HORNBY
Made in China" rather than the drawgear
springing described on the larger wagons above.
More obvious however is that the correct G-Plates
are on a steel channel rather than wooden
solebar! Similarly, on the inside the bottom and
side doors are reproduced in some detail but this
effect is spoilt by circular moulding marks in
each corner and really demand some residual coal
to hide them! Measuring
14'5" x 7'0" x 4'0", I.W. Baldwin
wagon 15 was slightly wider but shallower than
fleetmate 22 built by Gloucester RCW in January
1910. Number 22 was also painted chocolate with
white lettering shaded black and rather than list
every product just mentioned that the Ruardean
based firm as sole agent for East Cannock
Colliery ( Staffordshire ) and stated "Empty
to Lydney Jcn.
As well as working as a
factor at several of the Forest of Dean
collieries - including Lightmoor, Eastern United
and Arthur & Edward - Ivo Baldwin also owned
the Harrow Hill pit from October 1921 to March
1924 and Addis Hill Colliery between 1931 and
1935. By the end of this period however, Ivo
Baldwin owed money to the Crawshay Brothers and
offered a car and plant from the colliery as part
payment.
Wagon 15 was one of two let
on deferred payment over seven years and in April
1908 six 10 ton second hand wagons were let to
Ivo Baldwin on a similar seven year scheme,
repair contracts eventually stretching to 1922.
As it would have been difficult for I.W. Baldwin
to trade with just eight wagons, it is possible
that his fleet also included vehicles supplied by
other manufacturers.
|
6 PLANK OPEN WAGONS SIDE
DOOR ONLY
|
 |
| S.J. MORELAND & SONS |
1
|
5-5-3
|
10T
|
1906
|
PL395
|
AS PER PLATE
|
| Hornby
Reference R6237. Back in the "bad old
days" of private owner coal wagon modelling
( about 1981 if my memory serves me right! )
Hornby offered a free special edition of this
Gloucester icon to anyone buying one of their
larger steam locomotives. I have not seen one of
those wagons this century ( please email me if you have a picture ) but the
current model has a lot going for it. White wall tyres and G.W. Co No 4
axle box embossing aside, the paintwork,
markings, wooden solebar and body ironmongery and
plates are all correct according to official
photograph 3300, taken in November 1906 to record
the six plank wagon. Of particular note is the
diamond shaped Great Western Railway converted
registration plate inside the brake gear
v-hanger, indicating - in this case - that the15'
6" x 6' 10" x 4' wagon was rebuilt from
a dumb buffered vehicle to one with Gloucester
pattern self contained sprung buffers. In fact
the model also has some nice drawgear springing
detail on the underside!
As is the case with some
other model manufacturers, Hornby has in this
instance eschewed the account of this wagon being
"black with white lettering and lead colour
band with white band and lettering shaded black
and lead colour ends" and gone for the near
psychedelic option pictured above. I.W. Baldwin
may have plumped for an essay but Sammy Moreland
knew how to grab the consumer's eye a good half a
century before Andy Warhol!
The very small writing near
the tare weight reads " When empty to
Princess Royal Colliery Co ltd, Whitecroft, Nr
Lydney." ( more of which below and on the Dapol and
Grafar
models page ) and the only slight disappointments
in the model are the lack of inner door detail
and plank grain and the presence of circles at
each of the corners which need covering up with
matchbox crates or coal dust.
Samuel John Moreland was
born in Stroud in 1828, a year after the opening
of the Gloucester to Sharpness ship canal. He
moved with his family to Gloucester in 1834 and
followed his father into the booming timber
industry. The 1851 census listed him as a lath
renderer while by 1853 he was "sawing,
planing, moulding and lath rendering" and
1856 - a year before his marriage - found him
running a joinery works and producing "every
description of building timber". He even
made huts for the Britsh army during the Crimean
War but it was the foundation of his match
factory in 1867 - in a wooden shed that he built
himself - that brought him lasting fame.
Starting with lucifer and
vesta matches sold under the brand names
"Arctic", "Jack Tar" and
"Leopard", Samuel Moreland and his
helpers were quick to use new formulas for
phosphorous and usher in the era of the safety
match. Just like the booming Gloucester Wagon (
later Railway Carriage and Wagon) Company across
Bristol Road, Morelands had easy access to the
Gloucester and Berkeley for the import of timber
- including Russian aspen - and the railways to
take away finished products.
Although facing competition
from Russia and Poland where both labour and raw
materials were cheap, Samuel Moreland thrived
through strong sales promotion. The World famous
"England's Glory" brand was acquired on
the closure of rival matchmaker Thomas Gee in
1891 and box artwork featured the revolutionary
twin turret battleship "HMS
Devastation", launched in 1871 and in Royal
Navy service until 1908. This was an era of
British pride in both home grown technology and
the expanding Empire! Harry Moreland, son of
Samuel, later introduced and chose the jokes on
the back of the boxes.
In 1897 the British Trade
Journal noted that Morelands had two steam
engines to provide power for splint and box
making and hot air drying machines while by 1907
the factory was employing 640 people. Morelands
survived the introduction of Match Tax and
shortages of timber and chlorate of potash ( used
to make match heads ) during World War One and
made striker sticks for bombs between 1939 and
1945.
Morelands was taken over by
Bryant and May in the early 1970s and production
at Bristol Road ceased in 1975 - less than a
decade after the last complete vehicle was
assembled at the Wagon Works opposite. The
Morelands factory is now a trading estate - still
identified by its famous neon sign - and although
England's Glory matches are still available,
these are made by Volvo subsidiary Swedish Match
in Uppsala.
|
5 PLANK LONG WHEELBASE
OPEN WAGONS LONG SIDE KNEES AND SIDE DOORS
|
 |
| CROOK & GREENWAY |
2
|
5-8-0
|
8T
|
1911
|
PL140
|
LITTLE MORE ACCURATE THAN DAPOL |
| Hornby
Reference R6235. Gloucester RCW official
photograph 3785 shows a five plank wagon, but
with round topped ends slightly higher than the
sides, white wall tyres and vertical door
ironmongery painted completely black. The side
knees also do not extend over the solebar, where
two G-Plates are located just to the left of the
brake gear V hanger. Instead, Hornby - by using a
standard moulding - somewhat derails itself in
historical terms by placing the two G-plates just
outboard of the side knees - on a C-section metal
rather than flat wooden solebar. This wagon also
substitutes underside detail for the words
"HORNBY Made in China", lacks interior
door detail but retains the circular moulding
marks in each corner. In its favour though is the
correct ( on leaving the factory ) 5-8-0 tare
weight instead of the 5-1-11as applied to the
Dapol model. The
real14'6" x 6'11" x 3'2" wagon may
have been a replacement for an earlier vehicle as
Crook & Greenway wagon 5 - a six plank 10 ton
wagon with two side doors - was the subject of a
Gloucester RCW official photograph in July 1898
painted lead colour with white letters shaded
black. Five plank 8 ton fleetmate 10 meanwhile
was outshopped from Bristol Road in October 1899,
painted chocolate with white lettering shaded
black. Wagon 12 though was another 5 plank 8 ton
wagon, but this time painted a vey dark grey and,
according to Mr Montague, converted from Broad
Gauge in January 1910. What it had been doing
since the last GWR Broad Gauge train ran in 1892
is another matter!
|
 |
| PONTITHEL CHEMICAL |
7
|
5-12-2
|
8T
|
1897
|
PL469
|
ALMOST AS PER PLATE
|
| Hornby
Reference R6219, sold from 2003 as part of a
weathered trio of wagons including Mark Williams
9 ( see below ) and a larger Berthlwyd liveried
vehicle of unknown origin. As Pontithel fleet 7
is sold as weathered I will not complain about
the lack of white wall tyres! However, an early
wagon enthusiast seems to have made off with the
solebar G-Plates which should be mounted either
side of the brake gear V-hanger. On the other
hand, this can represent some of the works
attention required on my Wagon Repairs diorama
and a weathered wagon also makes a contrast to
the shiny better-than-new products being readied
for re-introduction to the various working
fleets. The underside and inside however lacks
detail and the corner circle problem persists.
Dimensions (new) were 14' 5" x 7' x 3'
1". |
 |
| SOMERSET TRADING COMPANY |
56
|
5-13-2
|
8T
|
1904
|
PL529
|
MARKINGS ALMOST AS PER
PLATE
|
| Hornby
Reference R 6234. On the other hand, this wagon
definitely should have white wall tyres. And
wooden solebars, with one G-Plate inside the
brake gear V-hanger, one to the left of it and
one just under the 5 in 56. Other discrepancies
between this model and the official GRCW
photograph from June 1904 are the diagonal side
bracing ( not prototypical ) and the legend
SOMERSET TRADING COMPANY which should stretch
from one corner plate to the other in the same
way that YEOVIL should fill the gap between side
knee and corner plate. underside and inside
remarks remain the same as above. The data above
the tare weight reads "Empty to Trafalgar
Colliery" ( near Bilson in the Forest of
Dean, which closed in 1925) and the wagon
dimensions are 14' 5" x 6' 11"' x 3'
1". The Somerset
Trading Company had outlets throughout its home
county and was headquartered at 25 West Quay,
Bridgwater. Still trading as late as 1935, the
company was a brick and tile manufacturer and
also dealt in timber, cement, slate, maure,
cattle cake, corn, salt, coke and coal.
|
4 PLANK OPEN WAGONS SIDE
DOOR ONLY
|
 |
| CLEE HILL GRANITE |
350
|
5-10-0
|
10T
|
1903
|
POPE 154
|
MARKINGS ALMOST AS
PER PLATE
|
| Hornby
Reference R 6232. The markings - G Plates
included - are accurate if not complete. Shame
about the design! Leaving the white wall tyres in
Bristol Road and the interior circular marks in
Margate ( although there is some nice underside
drawgear moulding ), this was a model with side
doors and wooden solebars representing a real
wagon with steel solebars and no doors between
the diagonal side bracing! On the positive side
however, at least the inner side planking is now
totally correct! The
Clee Hill Granite Company worked quarries near
Ludlow in Shropshire ( hence the white
"Empty to Ludlow" legend above the tare
weight ) and Severn & Wye Railway Letter
Books reveal that Clee Hill Granite Company fleet
number 431 was damaged at Lydney on 27 November
1904. It is likely that the wagon was bringing
stone to west Gloucestershire as there are many
references in contemporary local newspapers to
various councils using Clee Hill stone - being
more durable than Forest of Dean stone - for road
repairs.
Between 1897 and 1904 five
batches of similar four plank 14' 5" x 6'
11" x 2' 4" wagons were produced for
the Clee Hill Granite Company by the Gloucester
Railway Carriage & Wagon Company. The fleet
was distinguished by having the diagonal side
bracing picked out in a colour contrasting the
body shade as well as by having no doors at all:
a rare combination for Gloucester RCW!
The fleet of 101 wagons
began with lone 10 ton number 331, outshopped in
September 1897 with a 5-10-2 tare and also
bearing the name "Thos Roberts,
Manager" under the line "Return to
Ludlow". It was ordered in August 1897 and
paid for in cash, hence just one solebar G-Plate
was mounted just to the left of the brake gear
V-hanger. Another distinguishing feature was the
white red-shaded words LUDLOW, SALOP mounted
centrally on the bottom plank. The fleet number
was thus on the right hand side over the load
tonnage. In similar lettering across the top of
the side of the wagon were the words CLEE HILL
GRANITE CO.
It was not until June 1903
that a second order was placed, this time for
thirty new 10 tonners - including 350 as depicted
in Hornby model R6232. The model is accurate in
the livery elements it includes, but lacks the
white italic word "Comp" under the TE
in GRANITE and the further legend "Richd
Roberts Manager" beneath. The 30 new wagons
were to be paid for over seven years and were
also subject to a Gloucester RCW repair contract
- hence the two solebar and one bodyside G-Plate.
The June 1903 batch set the
standard for three more orders. Twenty more 10
ton wagons were ordered in August 1903 while
another thirty vehicles were ordered in December
1903. The late 1903 ordered wagons included fleet
numbers 375 and 398 ( photographed in May 1904 )
and a final order for 20 wagons came from
Shropshire to Bristol Road in October 1904.
In addition, the Clee Hill
Granite Company also hired twenty five second
hand 10 ton wagons from Gloucester RCW for seven
years from November 1906. The quarry firm also
operated a number of seven and three plank wagons
with side doors and the Birmingham Railway
Carriage and Wagon Company supplied an order for
twenty five 15-ton coal wagons numbered 500 to
524 in April 1913. These were probably the last
new wagons ordered by the Clee Hill Granite
Company before merging with Field & Mackay
and Clee Hill Dhu Stone to form the British
Quarrying Company in 1929.
The Clee Hill Granite
Company had commenced quarrying in 1867,
producing both graded roadstone and stone setts
for distribution via the Ludlow and Clee Hill
Light Railway and, on the other side of Clee Hill
at Catherton, crushed stone that was taken away
along the Cleobury Mortimer and Ditton Priors
Light Railway. Despite being more expensive than
its rival Leicestrian products, Clee Hill granite
was so hard wearing that it was used to pave
London's Piccadilly between Park Lane and Regent
Street and was used on busy roads in Gloucester
as well as hundreds of other English locations.
One ton of hand trimmed granite 3" x 4"
setts could cover a road area of 5 1/4 square
yards and in 1886 Gloucestershire County Council
used 7 739 tons - more than 770 wagon loads - to
make roads costing £ 120 a mile.
|
 |
| THE HARTS HILL IRON COMPANY |
6
|
5-11-2
|
10T
|
1911
|
PL267
|
MARKINGS ALMOST AS PER
PLATE
|
| Hornby
Reference R6233. The same basic model as above,
but this time the diagonal side bracing is
correct and the lack of internal door detail is
absent. The diagonal side bracing should also be
- as depicted in Gloucester RCW photograph 3789
of June 1911 - the same chocolate hue as the body
and the two G-Plates and the two G-plates on the
( correct ) wooden solebar should be either side
of the brake gear v-hanger. And there should be
white wall tyres! The data panel on the 14
'5" x 6' 11" x 2' 6" reads
"Empty to Park House Colly. Chesterton, N.S.
Ry" and although the North Staffordshire
Railway ( known as the "Knotty" after
its coat of arms ) is well documented, The Harts
Hill Iron Company is more obscure. Harts Hill
station on the Great Western Railway line between
Stourbridge Junction and Dudley only lasted from
1895 to 1916 and today the route is freight-only
- passing under the West Coast Main Line at
Dudley Port. However, this is the area of the
Black Country in which the anchors for the ill
fated RMS Titanic were made! |
 |
| MARK WILLIAMS |
9
|
5-11-0
|
10T
|
1910
|
PL641
|
ALMOST AS PER PLATE
|
| Hornby
Reference R6219, sold from 2003 as part of a
weathered trio of wagons including Pontithel 7 (
see above ) and a larger Berthlwyd liveried
vehicle of unknown origin. As Mark Williams 9 is
supplied as weathered I will not complain about
the lack of white wall tyres, and similarly
although Gloucester RCW photograph 3678 of June
1910 shows the diagonal side bracing as being the
same chocolate colour as the body this model
could easily represent ironwork painted black
after a previous repair. Certainly all three
G-Plates on the wooden solebar are correctly
positioned. Which is nice! The dimensions for
Mark Williams 9 are given as 14' 5" x 6'
11" x 3' 1" and interestingly Plate 38
in Bill Hudson's Oakwood Press book "Private
Owner Wagons" ( ISBN 0 85361 492 X ) shows a
May 1938 view of a John Williams & Co five
planker painted grey and numbered 76 but with the
words CHELTENHAM & GLOUCESTER in similar
lettering. Could they belong to the same firm
perhaps? |
 |
PRINCESS
ROYAL
|
56
|
16-10
|
10T
|
?
|
POPE
54
|
POSSIBLY NOT EVEN
GLOUCESTER RCW |
| Hornby
Reference 6282. Hornby were modelling Princess
Royal Colliery wagon 250 ( the same number as
chosen by Grafar ) as part of its prestigious
"Silver Seal" range way back in 1975.
Fleet number 56 however is far less well
documented, even Ian Pope only having a rather
blurred shot of the four plank wagon in a very
faded, careworn state during World War II with a
white diagonal stripe along the diagonal side
bracing to indicate a tipping end. This alone
makes Hornby model R6282 inaccurate, but the
photograph also shows a wagon with four very deep
planks, giving it a height and proportion more
like that of a seven planker. By the Second World
War as well, any G-Plates had disappeared.
Although it is highly likely that Princess Royal
Colliery bought its wagons from The Gloucester
Railway Carriage and Wagon Company, the precise
origin of wagon 56 cannot be proved. The italic
script on the drop down door reads "Empty to
Princess Royal Colliery Severn & Wye Joint
Railway." Although
first galed in 1842, the Princess Royal Colliery
Company was not incorporated until December 1890
and finally the mine - located close to today's
Dean Forest Railway - closed in March 1962.
|
3 PLANK DROPSIDE OPEN
WAGONS
|
 |
| EASTER IRON MINES |
4
|
5-7-0
|
10T
|
1911
|
PL184
|
AS PL BUT CURVED ENDS |
| Hornby
Reference R6230. Inner planking detail of this
dropside wagon is correct ( corner rings apart )
although the ends should really have a curve up
above the sides. The ironwork should also match
the chocolate bodyside if Gloucester RCW
photograph 3834 of November 1911 is to be adhered
to and although it shows three G-Plates on either
side of the brake gear V-hanger on the wooden
solebar the photograph also shows the lettering
to be correct - even if the white wall tyres are
absent. The italic lettering reads "Empty to
Milkwall, GWR & Mid Severn & Wye Joint
Rly" and dimensions are 14' 5" x 6'
1" x 1' 8". The
Forest of Dean coalfield lies on top of iron ore
deposits which formed in the crease limestone.
From early times iron was mined around the edge
of the area leaving telltale "scowles",
which supplied ore to blast furnaces fuelled by
charcoal made from Forest trees. Later, deep
mining was introduced, especially around the
Cinderford, Milkwall and Bream areas. Some of the
rich Forest of Dean iron ore was exported to
south Wales, although coke fired blast furnaces
also appeared at Cinderford, Parkend and
Soudeley. This in turn led to the growth of
tinplate and wire works and foundries, the latter
often making castings for mine use. However, by
the 20th Century cheaper foreign ores were
undercutting prices in the Forest of Dean and the
last major iron mine at Shakemantle, south of
Cinderford, closed in 1899. The last blast
furnace in Cinderford had already closed in 1894
although tinplate continued to be made in Lydney
until 1957.
Easter Iron Mine was first
galed in April 1846 and was worked by the Barrett
Brothers until August 1874. Ore would have been
transported along the horse drawn Milkwall
Tramroad for transshipment at Parkend until the
opening of the Severn & Wye Railway Coleford
branch in July 1875, by which time the gale was
being worked by the Easter Haematite Iron Ore
Company Limited. This concern lasted from 1874 to
1884, during which time a range of second hand
wagons was leased from the Gloucester Railway
Carriage and Wagon Company.
The Easter Iron Mine was
then taken over by the Milkwall Ironstone
Company, formed in 1910. In November 1911 the
company bought six 10 ton wagons - including
number 4 -on seven years deferred payment from
Gloucester RCW. In July 1916 however the Milkwall
Ironstone Company sold out to the Easter Iron ore
Mines Ltd which went into voluntary liquidation
in 1924. The mine buildings at Milkwall alongside
the Sling Branch then passed to the British
Colour & Mining Company Limited, who used
iron ore to make red and ochre pigments for
paints.
|
|
|